Skip to main content

On RBG, Laurel and Hardy


RBG, Laurel and Hardy

One of the finer documentaries of 2018 is RBG which covers the trail-blazing career of liberal U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg (who turns 86 on March 15).  A multiple award winner, including being named best documentary by the National Board of Review, it’s a contender for an Oscar nomination to be announced January 22.
            Director Mimi Leder’s narrative takes a rather jaunty inspirational melodrama approach to its subject, focusing on the period from 1956, when Bader Ginsburg (Felicity Jones) was among a handful of women admitted to the Harvard Law School, to the 1970s when she, representing a male client, won a groundbreaking case before a federal appeals court that hinged on overturning gender discrimination in tax legislation. From the outset, and in that seminal case, Bader Ginsberg, then a law professor, was strongly backed by supportive home husband and fellow lawyer Martin Ginsberg (Armie Hammer), who overcame cancer to become a partner in a prestigious law firm. Bader Ginsberg had to overcome many obstacles, notably skeptical men in high places such as the Harvard law school dean Erwin Griswold (Sam Waterston) who was Attorney General at the time she argued the celebrated 1970s case.  She also had to convince the reluctant male head of the American Civil Liberties Union to make common cause.
            On the Basis of Sex closes with a few clips of the real RBG from her Supreme Court tenure (she was pointed to the court by Jimmy Carter in 1980) but that’s all it shows from the last four decades of her remarkable career.  Within those limitations the film does a passable job.  However the documentary RBG is the one to see for a much deeper and fuller portrait.
            Justice Bader Ginsburg has had some serious health issues recently.  (She was released from hospital Christmas day after a cancer-related surgery.) So one has to hope she hangs in there and outlasts President Donald Trump who has already made two appointments to the high court, the last a controversial ultra-conservative male judge accused of sexual assault.  B

Stan & Ollie (UK/Canada/U.S. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stan_%26_Ollie)
This delightful, and candid, ode to the legendary comedy duo of Stan Laurel (Steve Coogan) and Oliver Hardy (John C. Reilly) did not reach Canadian shores until this month.   
            Reilly has been a busy recently—in The Sisters Brothers, the voice of Ralph in the popular animated feature Ralph Breaks the Internet, and as Dr. Watson in Holmes & Watson, the latter and unfortunately rather lamentable pairing with funny man Will Ferrell as the famous fictional sleuth.  He fares much better here as Ollie, aided by prosthetics to portray the portly sidekick affectionately known as “Babe”.
            The film opens in Culver City, California 1937 as the pair stroll through studio sets and sound stages until performing a comic pose for the camera in front of a Western backdrop.  We then jump to a packed movie palace audience convulsed in laugher as the same black-and-white scene unfolds on the screen. It a glorious shot setup of movie make-believe and magic.  From this career highpoint the picture fast forwards 16 years to Britain 1953 and the duo’s twilight years doing a tour of variety halls as part of getting the production greenlight for a planned Robin Hood comedy.  (The screenplay is based on A.J. Marriot’s 1993 book Laurel & Hardy: The British Tours.)  At first audiences for their trademark stage routines are sparse but public- appearance promotions pay off in a sold-out engagement at London’s Lyceum theatre. Laurel’s bitchy Russian wife Ida (Nina Arianda) and Hardy’s wife Lucille (Shirley Henderson) join them at the swank Savoy hotel.
            While the longtime partners get past a tiff over part recriminations, and the news that the picture deal is off, Hardy’s collapse from a mild heart attack is a more serious blow.  Their devotion to each other is such that Laurel is unable to continue the show with another comedian, and Hardy, ignoring doctors’ advice, returns to the stage for a triumphant Irish tour. It will be their final act.  The movie recalls their comic genius, and brilliant performances by Reilly and Coogan bring to life the ups and downs of an era that appreciated their innocent form of standup humour.  A- 
           


  
 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Best of 2018: My Choices for the Best Dramas and Documentaries

The Best of 2018 Notwithstanding the popularity of at-home streaming services led by Netflix, movie-going to theatres is not declining.Indeed in 2018 North American attendance is up with a record box office of almost US$12 billion. Even if much of this is for tentpole blockbusters centred on comic characters, the big screen appeals more broadly.Take the case of my best movie of the year, the Spanish-language Roma.A Netflix production available online since December 14, the large Ottawa theatre where I saw it a second time was still packed for a post-Christmas showing in a 10-day run. Good news indeed.
10 Best Narrative Features 1.Roma (Mexico/U.S.) Viewed on the big screen the immersive luminous black-and-white cinematography and ambient soundscape is even more impressive in this semi-autobiographical masterwork from Alfonso Cuarón which features a sublime performance by first-time actor Yalitza Aparicio as the central figure of Cleo, the Indigenous nanny-housemaid in an upper-class Mexi…

Upcoming Book: The Best of Screenings & Meanings: A Journey through Film

“The art of filmmaking is the most influential form of art that has ever existed throughout the history of human artistic endeavors.”  ~ ABHIJIT NASKAR, THE FILM TESTAMENT
FORTHCOMING SUMMER 2018

The Best of Screenings & Meanings: A Journey through Film The conclusion of my weekly Screenings & Meanings columns has prompted me to put together an anthology drawn from 35 years of film comment along with some new material specifically for this volume.  Watch for the volume to become available soon. 

Roma: Netflix Brings the Best Movie of the Year

Netflix Brings the Best of 2018: Roma

Roma
         If you don’t have Netflix it would be worth getting it just to watch this Mexican masterwork as it will have only a very limited theatrical release.  Roma, which won the Venice film festival’s top prize, is the year’s best reviewed film with reason.  I’ve added below one among many laudatory reviews.
        Let me add a few notes to that.  The story, set in the “Roma” residential neighborhood of Mexico City 1970-71, obviously draws on director Cuarón’s personal memories.  It combines strikingly evocative images, a cinematic poetry, with remarkable realism, so much so that at times you could swear you were watching a black-and-white documentary from that period.  The class structure is apparent: the lower orders with Indigenous blood (a majority of Mexicans are ‘mestizo’- mixed race) serve well-to-do households like the one depicted in the film—a professional couple with five children (four boys and a girl) and a grandmother living with…